Kettlebells vs. Cardio Q’n’A

  QChris, guys like you and Craig Ballantyne hate cardio so much and I’m not sure why. I’ve been a runner for over 15 years now and I’ve been training with weights for only a few years. I’ve found that running is the only type of exercise to give me the long, lean dancer look that I’m after. In my experience, weight training has only made me feel big & bulky. What gives? Why do you hate cardio so much?

-Geraldine, Charleston, North Carolina, USA
 

A: Hi Geraldine. "Hate" is a very strong word, but yes, you’re right… 

I do HATE cardio.

My choice to not use cardio with my clients (or in any of my programs) is more of a lifestyle choice than anything else. All of the people I deal with are sick of the BS and don’t have time to devote hours and hours in the their week to running, biking or doing whatever it is that people do on an elliptical machine.

Choosing to train using bodyweight, free weights and kettlebells is more of a quality vs. quantity decision. 

Sure, someone can spend an hour a day jogging on a treadmill at 60% of their max effort. But, if it’s better for you to work at intervals of 80-90% of your max effort and get better results in half (or even 1/3) of the time, then why wouldn’t you do it?

Research has already shown that you can get the same cardiovascular benefits doing interval training that you can when you do traditional long, slow cardio.  And the best part about it is that interval training isn’t limited to just some form of repetitive exercise (like running/sprinting or riding a bike).

In fact, the more variety of movement you get when you do your high intensity work, the less likely it is that you’ll get an overuse injury.

For example, for my interval training I’ll do combination of hill sprints and 2-Arm KB Swings.

There’s a great hill close to my house that overlooks the Toronto skyline. I’ll head over there with my 24kg kettlebell and after a good warm-up I’ll run up the hill as fast as I can. At the top, I’ll pick-up my KB and do 60-90s of swings, then I’ll walk back down the hill for recovery.

To progress, I did a combination of adding an additional sprint each successive week or I increased the number of swings I did.

This was a great combo because the extreme "uni-lateral" (or 1-legged) hip flexion involved in sprinting up a steep hill was the perfect compliment to the "bi-lateral" (or 2-legged) hip extension of the 2-arm swings.

Sprinting hills is also a very safe way to do interval training because it uses a limited range of motion so it reduces the chances of someone pulling a hamstring or a quad muscle.

If you train at home, then a bodyweight or kettlebell circuit would be just as effective.

Remember, it’s about 1) working hard beyond your level of comfort for short but intense bouts and 2) using a variety of movements.

OK, so in saying all of that, there are 3 instances where I’m an advocate of "cardio".

First, for transportation. I ride my bike to work as often as possible because I love being outside and it doesn’t make sense to drive a car in the city. Riding a bike is the easiest way to get around when you live in an urban area.

Second, for competition. If you’re a competitive runner or cyclist and race for a living, then you have to train specific to your event to get better at it. But ask any competitive athlete and they’ll tell you how important it is to make sure that you partake a complimentary resistance training program to stave off injury and stay healthy for competition.

And third, if you love it. If you absolutely LOVE to get out there and pound your joints or get saddle burn from being on your butt for 4 hours, then who am I to judge? Shoot, I love cheesecake, and regardless what any dietician or nutritionist says, I’d eat a slice of NY Cheesecake with blueberry sauce everyday and twice on Sunday if I could.

But remember, people come to me to consult them on the BEST way to lose fat and get lean. And the absolute best way to get lean and look great is through proper resistance and interval training (and eating a healthy diet).

So if you’re just running (or doing cardio) to get in shape or lose fat, then using KBs and/or free weights and bodyweight training is a far superior. 

Stop wasting your time doing anything else.

-Chris

p.s. You can stop doing cardio and start losing insane amounts of fat by doing Kettlebell Workouts … Click HERE to get started.

5 Comments

  • Reply December 7, 2009

    Craig Ballantyne

    Hi Geraldine,

    If someone likes doing cardio, that’s fine, and if they are having fun, getting results, and staying injury free, then cardio is fine.

    But…

    Almost everyone that I have trained in person or who has emailed me for help is getting ZERO results from cardio, hates doing it, is hurting from it, and is very frustrated.

    Those are the people I create my programs for, and those are the people I am helping.

    And that’s why I dislike cardio – and I dislike articles and trainers who tell poor beginners that cardio is the only way to go for fat loss.

    Plus, most people don’t have time to do long cardio workouts – and they don’t need to.

    Craig

  • Reply December 7, 2009

    Joe

    great post!

    I love LOVE using your 10 minute KB workouts. As a new dad, I just don’t have enough time in the day to be at the gym everyday..With your 10 minute kb workouts, I can adjust depending on how much time I have.

    Today, I did the 20 x 10 and 10 x 20 with some treadmill walking (for rest) in between..man, its intense! Thanks!!!

  • Reply December 8, 2009

    Herminator

    Hey Craig!

    Read your response to the runner. I’m 52 and run full marathons and just love the cleansing effect I get from the run. However, my training would be incomplete without cross-training; i.e., weights, kettlebells, pushups, etc.. Cross-trainging aguments my training without bulking me up. End result, my run is stronger and recovery is quicker.
    The body (our bodies) needs to get out off routine. when we do that, the muscle stays stimulated and when the muscle is stimulated or shocked–results are inevitable–leaner, stronger and faster.
    I not only speak from experience, but also from an educational background of exercise science and nutrition.
    I hope your runner gives “interval” another shot, it’s a benefit that can’t be ignored. AND, let’s not forget the freshness your workouts will now have.
    Have a terrific and healthy week, Herman

  • Reply December 8, 2009

    Sandy Sommer, RKC

    I’ve found that most of my clients who are runners (recreational, not competitive) quickly give up the pounding once introduced to kettlebells. A great concept. HIT without joint pain, sore feet and the general wear and tear of road running. That said, IMHO those of us who don’t point our clients in the direction of solid nutritional education do them a disservice by claiming that anything “melts” fat. You just can’t outwork a bad diet.

    Train with purpose,

    Sandy Sommer, RKC

  • Reply January 7, 2010

    Cross Fit Old Bethpage

    […] Tracey sent me a link about short intense training, good stuff. http://kettlebellworkouts.com/2009/12/kettlebells-vs-cardio-qna/ […]

Leave a Reply